Tylenol Murders Case Study Analysis
THE TYLENOL MURDERS ) “The Tylenol Muders! Crisis Co""uni#ation $ssue Handled
The Case Study Information
During the early 1*+,s- Tylenol .e#a"e one o/ the "ost su##ess/ul o(er0the0#ounter rodu#ts "ade .y 2ohnson 3 2ohnson in the United States4 The rodu#t 5as resonsi.le /or "orethan 1* er#ent o/ the #o"any6s ro/its in 1*+)4 $t lead the industry in .eing the nu".er one ain7iller /or #onsu"ers- outselling the other /our leading .rands- in#luding 'ayer- !na#in- 'u//erin- and E8#edrin 9'erge- 1**,4Un/ortunately- the #o"any and their nu".er one .rand- Tylenol- too7 a turn /or the 5orse4 $n O#to.er 1*+)- se(en indi(iduals li(ing in Chi#ago 5ere reorted dead a/ter ta7ing 2ohnson 3 2ohnson6s E8tra0Strength Tylenol #asules4 $t 5as /ound that an un7no5n suse#t ta"ered 5ith the .ottles and inserted "ore than ;< "illigra"s o/ deadly #yanide into the #asules4 This e8#essi(e a"ount is 1,-,,, ti"es "ore than the ne#essary a"ount to 7ill a hu"an .eing4 $t 5as dis#o(ered that the #asule ta"ering o##urred on#e the .ottles 5ere already la#ed .a#7 on the shel(es4 The suse#t had re"o(ed the"- oisoned the ills 5ith #yanide- and ut the" .a#7 on the shel(es /or indi(iduals to ur#hase4On#e there 5as a #lear #onne#tion .et5een the se(en reorted deaths and the Tylenol- announ#e"ents 5ere "ade to the u.li# 5arning the" a.out the dangerous #yanide oisonings4 The #o"any 5as le/t 5ith the dile""a o/ ho5 to handle the #risis situation and "aintain a good reutation /or the"sel(es during this ti"e4 2ohnson 3 2ohnson held an urgent re#all on the #onta"inated rodu#t- #onsisting o/ =1 "illion .ottles nation5ide and losing "ore than >1,, "illion dollars in ro/its /or the #o"any4 $n addition to the re#all- 2ohnson 3 2ohnson susended all ad(ertise"ents /or the Tylenol rodu#t in the ti"e o/ the #risis4
Revisiting Tylenol Poisoning Scare
The 1980’s Tylenol poisoning murders spurred panic, wide-spread fear, and perhaps the best-ever corporate response to a major public relations crisis. James E. Burke, then CEO of Tylenol-maker Johnson & Johnson, died on September 28 at the age of 87. He will be best known for his strong, decisive leadership and what has widely been recognized as a model of exceptional corporate crisis management. Fortune magazine named him one of history’s 10 greatest CEOs because of his handling of the Tylenol scare.
There are 5 crisis management truths we can learn from Mr. Burke’s handling of the poisoning disaster—lessons in the right way to handle a public relations nightmare.
1. Be forthcoming and honest
In 1982, seven people died after taking capsules of Extra-Strength Tylenol that had been laced with cyanide. The sabotage spurred a national panic about the safety of over-the-counter medications, and threatened the very survival of Johnson & Johnson. Tylenol products represented one-fifth of J&J’s revenue at the time.
J&J was careful to point out that, based on the evidence, the tampering must have occurred at the retail stores. However, they did not attempt to shift blame. They were extremely candid.
James E. Burke with an oversize model of the Tylenol that replaced capsules. Image credit: William E. Sauro, The NY Times
Burke “spoke the truth and that was astonishingly liberating for everyone who heard it because we have all become so accustomed to public figures telling less than the truth or lying,” wrote Harvard business professor Richard Tedlow.
2. Act quickly and decisively
According to Tedlow, on the afternoon of the first deaths, the company:
- set up toll-free numbers manned by company employees
- sent 450,000 telex messages to doctors’ offices, hospitals and trade groups
- stopped all Tylenol advertising
On the first day.
3. Take responsibility, even if you don’t have to
Less than one week after the deaths, J&J spent more than $100 million recalling 32 million bottles of Tylenol capsules from store shelves. According to a Harvard Business School case study of the incident, the heads of the FDA and FBI felt that a recall would be an overreaction. J&J’s management put customer safety ahead of their financial concerns.
The company also established relations with the Chicago Police Department, FDA and FBI to maintain a role in searching for the person responsible for the deaths, and became the first company to adopt new triple-seal tamper-resistant packaging rules.
4. Treat people with respect
Within months, J&J re-introduced Tylenol capsules to consumers. It distributed over 40 million $2.50 coupons (enough to purchase a good-size bottle) to compensate customers who threw away Tylenol during the scare. They also created a new pricing program that saved consumers up to 25%.
In a 1986 news conference, Mr. Burke announced that Johnson & Johnson would stop selling over-the-counter products in capsules, which could be tampered with, and switch to solid caplets. When asked by a reporter if he was sorry the company had not acted sooner. Mr. Burke replied “Yes, indeed I am.”
5. Good behavior pays dividends
As the tough decisions were being made by Mr. Burke and his executive team, many were skeptical. They warned that the company’s reputation would never recover. Time has proved them wrong.
Less than a year after re-launching Tylenol, J&J regained a 30% share of the market and once again became the top-selling pain reliever. Today, Tylenol enjoys the highest ratings for consumer confidence, and is the most prescribed over-the-counter pain reliever.
Ultimately, the decisions were part of a shrewd plan to salvage the reputation and revenue of J&J, and return Tylenol to commanding market share. Even so, Mr. Burke proved that putting the customer first can reap greater rewards than a short-sighted drive to deflect blame and protect share price.
Maintaining a “reservoir of trust” among customers helped see J&J through this defining crisis, and in a 2003 Harvard Business School profile, Mr. Burke noted that “Nothing good happens without trust. With it, you can overcome all sorts of obstacles.”
MissionMode’s smarter mass notification and incident management applications enable organizations to take control of crises, and reduce the time and cost of the response. Contact us today for more information or to schedule a demonstration.
Image credit, Tylenol capsules: Leif Skoogfors, CORBIS